Mon-Sun: 5AM-4PM (3PM SAT/SUN)

Welcome to Bagel Pantry

Serving great food for more than 26 years!

Welcome to Bagel Pantry, a culinary haven with a rich legacy spanning 26 years!

In 1983, one out of the three founders of Bagel Pantry immigrated from Palestine to The United States and ended up right here in New Jersey. He worked in several Bagel Shops around the state and when two of his other brothers also immigrated from Palestine, they decided to open up a shop of their own.

On February 17, 1997 Bagel Pantry opened for business. At the time, there was only one location, on Plainfield Avenue in South Plainfield. However, as business grew, the brothers expanded and opened up another shop in Metuchen and Millburn. Over the years, the store grew into the hearts of locals and became a tradition in South Plainfield, Metuchen, & Millburn.


We have 3 Bagel Pantry Locations

South Plainfield, NJ

134 South Plainfield Ave, South Plainfield, NJ 07080

Phone: 908-791-0078

Metuchen, NJ

545 Middlesex Ave, Metuchen, NJ 08840

Phone: 732-632-3100

Millburn, NJ

518 Millburn Ave, Short Hills, NJ 07078

Phone: 973-939-1741


We'll cater your event!

Birthday Parties

Call for Price

Celebrate your special day with flavor and flair! Bagel Pantry is delighted to bring our culinary expertise to your birthday bash. Our catering services promise a delectable spread of handcrafted delights, from our signature bagels to gourmet sandwiches and more. Elevate your festivities with the distinctive taste of Bagel Pantry, where every bite is a celebration of delicious moments. Let us cater to your cravings, making your birthday party an unforgettable culinary experience!


Call for Price

Give thanks with a feast that's nothing short of extraordinary! Bagel Pantry is here to cater your Thanksgiving gathering with a delectable spread that captures the essence of the season. From our mouthwatering turkey sandwiches to indulgent sides and desserts, savor the warmth and joy of the holiday without the stress of cooking. Let us handle the details while you focus on creating cherished memories with your loved ones. This Thanksgiving, elevate your celebration with the distinctive taste of Bagel Pantry, where each dish is crafted to make your gratitude-filled moments truly special.

Work Events

Call for Price

Elevate your work events with a touch of culinary excellence from Bagel Pantry! Whether it's a corporate meeting, conference, or team-building gathering, our catering services bring a delicious fusion of flavors to your workplace. From gourmet sandwiches to artisanal salads and more, our menu caters to diverse tastes, making your work event memorable and tastefully satisfying. Let Bagel Pantry handle the catering details, leaving you free to focus on what truly matters – building connections and achieving success. Make your work events exceptional with the distinctive taste and quality service of Bagel Pantry, where every bite is a step towards a successful and flavorful collaboration.


What they're saying about us